Strathgartney Homestead National Historic Site of Canada
Bonshaw, Prince Edward Island
Aerial view
(© Strathgartney Foundation/La fondation Strathgartney, circa 1960.)
Address :
Trans Canada Highway 1, Bonshaw, Prince Edward Island
Recognition Statute:
Historic Sites and Monuments Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. H-4)
Designation Date:
1997-09-22
Dates:
-
1861 to 1868
(Construction)
-
1861 to 1876
(Significant)
Event, Person, Organization:
-
Passing of the Land Purchase Act of 1875
(Event)
-
Robert Bruce Stewart (1813-1884)
(Person)
Other Name(s):
-
Strathgartney Homestead
(Designation Name)
Research Report Number:
1996-054, 2005-126
Plaque(s)
Plaque Removed: Prince Edward Island
Strathgartney Homestead recalls an era when a small group of proprietors controlled most of the land on Prince Edward Island. In the 1860s the largest of the few resident landowners, Robert Bruce Stewart, developed this site to be the centrepiece of his estate. For his tenant farmers, however, Strathgartney symbolized the unfairness of leasehold tenure, a system that ended after legislation in 1875 gave tenants across the Island the right to buy the land they farmed. Strathgartney is a vivid reminder of the land tenure system that dominated Island life for more than a century.
Description of Historic Place
Strathgartney Homestead National Historic Site of Canada is a 32-acre (12.9 ha) remnant of the 500-acre (202.3 ha) estate of Robert Bruce Stewart, a nineteenth-century landowner. It contains the Stewart house, a carriage house and a collection of seven farm outbuildings from the Stewart period set in an agricultural landscape.
Heritage Value
Strathgartney Homestead was designated a national historic site in 1996 because: it is an important reminder of the land tenure system that dominated political and social life on Prince Edward Island for over a century, it illuminates the broader debate over the Land Question in the decades leading to the Land Purchase Act of 1875. To its owner, Robert Bruce Stewart, the estate embodied the rights of property and for Island tenants, it pointed to the inequity of leasehold tenure.
The heritage value of this site resides in the buildings and landscape that constitute the Strathgartney Homestead as remnant survivals, symbolic of the role of the Stewart family in the land tenure history of the island and their ability to illustrate the lifestyle of the Stewart family.
The Strathgartney estate was constructed by Robert Bruce Stewart in the early 1860s and run by his family until 1876 when they left in response to the 1875 approval of the Land Purchase Act. The homestead has been much changed since that time.
Source: HSMBC Minutes, 19-20 November 1996, p. 39-40.
Character-Defining Elements
Key features contributing to the heritage value of this site include:
the large unadorned residence and its associated outbuildings dating from the period of Stewart occupancy (the carriage house, cattle barn, horse barn, hen house, granary building, coach house, blacksmith's shop and boat house) in their found materials and forms, particularly those standing on their original locations, the residence with its cross-gable massing and large porch, the vernacular forms and wood materials (clapboard and shingle) of outbuildings dating from the period of Stewart occupancy (carriage house, cattle barn, horse barn, hen house, granary building, coach house, blacksmith's hope, and boat house), evidence of the early spatial relationships between the buildings on the site (with particular emphasis on those buildings occupying their original locations), the secluded setting of the Homestead on a high elevation in a peaceful, rural clearing exhibiting remnants of a formal garden, woods, and rolling countryside.