Report tabled and approved by the Audit Committee and the Evaluation Committee
[ Previous | Table of Contents ]
Table 1: Planned Spending for 2008-2009
Table 2: Internal Audit Projects Carried forward from 2007-2008
Table 3: Evaluation Projects Carried Forward From 2007-2008
Table 4: MAF Universe and Scheduled Audit Projects for 2008-2009 and 2009-2010
Table 5: Internal Audit Project Scheduling for 2008-2009
Table 6: PAA Universe and Five-Year Evaluation Schedule
Table 7: Evaluation Project Scheduling for 2008-2009
Table 8: 2008-2009 Capacity For Internal Audit and Evaluation
Table 9: Comparison of 2008 and 2007 MAF Universe Elements and Links to Draft Core Management Controls
Table 10: Comparison of 2008 and 2007 PAA Universe Elements
Table 11: Comparison of MAF 2007 and 2008 Ratings
Table 12: Results of 2008 MAF Assessement
Table 13: Comparison of PAA 2007 and 2008 Ratings
Table 14: Result of 2008 PAA Assessment
Table 1: Planned Spending for 2008-2009
| CAEE Office |
Internal Audit |
Evaluation |
Total |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FTEs |
2 |
6 |
3 |
11 |
| Salary |
36,297 |
433,390 |
215,383 |
685,070 |
| Benefits |
7,259 |
86,678 |
43,077 |
137,014 |
| Accommodations |
4,719 |
56,341 |
28,000 |
89,059 |
| Sub Total |
48,275 |
576,408 |
286,459 |
911,143 |
| O&M For Staff Support |
12,500 |
37,500 |
18,750 |
68,750 |
| O&M for Professional Services |
17,637 |
156,559 |
243,418 |
417,614 |
| Auditor Training and Certification Funds |
30,000 |
30,000 |
||
| Audit Committee Funds |
135,000 |
|
|
135,000 |
| Sub Total O&M |
165,137 |
224,059 |
262,168 |
651,364 |
| Grand Total |
213,412 |
800,467 |
548,627 |
1,562,506 |
The FTE for the CAEE is included in the table but not the salary, and associated benefit and accommodations costs, which are administered centrally for all executive level employees in the Agency. Table does not include carry forward amounts from 2007-2008 that were not yet allocated. |
||||
Table 2: Internal Audit Projects Carried forward from 2007-2008
| Topic |
Type |
Description |
Planned or Actual Dates |
Comments |
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planned 2007-08 |
Start Date |
Completion of the fieldwork |
Completion of Report |
Date of Approval by Committee** |
||||
| National Level Finance & Administrative Management Control Framework |
Description and survey* |
Develop description and survey of the corporate management control framework for finance & administration |
Y |
Jan 08 |
May 08 |
June 08 |
Sept 08 |
This project was delayed by approximately 7 months in order to respond to other unplanned projects requested by management |
| Financial and Administrative Controls |
Assurance |
Audits related to contracting, travel claims; accounts payable, revenue, inventory, and financial coding |
||||||
National Parks Directorate |
Y |
Dec 07 |
Feb 08 |
Jan 08 |
Sept 08 |
|||
DG East |
Y |
Oct 07 |
Nov 07 |
April 08 |
Sept 08 |
|||
Offices of DG North & West |
Y |
Nov 07 |
Dec 07 |
May 08 |
Sept 08 |
|||
| Information Technology / Information system |
Description and Survey |
Develop description and survey of major IT governance, risks and controls related to systems, information continuity, system application controls/security, system integration and systems under development |
Y |
April 08 |
Oct. 08 |
Dec. 08 |
March 09 |
Project completion is delayed approximately 1 year due to taking substantial more time than anticipated to develop and award a contract to complete the work (i.e., not awarded until March 2008). |
| Information Management and Privacy |
Description and Survey |
Description and survey of information management and privacy governance, risks and controls |
Y |
June 08 |
Nov 08 |
Jan 08 |
March 09 |
Project completion is delayed approximately 1 year. Originally it was expected that this project would be combined with the IT/IS project. Due to the scope and scale of that project it was decided to postpone the IM component until 2008-2009. |
| Follow-up Audits |
Follow-up |
Follow up audit on progress in implementation of management responses to the finance and administrative management audit of Northern Ontario FU. |
Y |
Dec 07 |
March 08 |
May 08 |
Sept 08 |
The fieldwork scheduled for January 08 was postponed to March 08 to accommodate field unit operations. Changes in field unit management have delayed the final debriefing on audit results until end of May, 2008 |
| Overtime Expenditures |
Description and Survey |
Initiated in response to risks identified by AG. |
N |
Dec. 08 |
Feb. 08 |
May 08 |
Sept 08 |
The project was not scheduled in the 2007-2008 Plan but will be delivered on time. |
* Description and survey refers to documenting governance, controls and risk management mechanisms related to the element in order to identify future areas within the element for audit work |
||||||||
Table 3: Evaluation Projects Carried Forward From 2007-2008
| Topic |
Type |
Description |
Planned or Actual Dates |
Comments |
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planned 2007-08 |
Start Date |
Completion of the fieldwork |
Completion of Report |
Date of Approval by Committee |
||||
| Asset Management and Capital Investment Program |
Evaluation |
This evaluation focuses on whether relevant assets are acquired and maintained and whether performance with respect to investment, compliance regimes and other program goals are met. |
Y |
May 06 |
March 08 |
June 08 |
Sept 08 |
The project has been delayed by six months as a result of difficulties in obtaining and reconciling key information on the number, value and condition of assets and in documenting prioritization and planning process. |
| Through Highways Management |
Description and Framework* |
A description of the framework and objectives for highway management and the systems in place to monitor relevance and performance as a basis for identifying future evaluation work. |
Y |
Jan 08 |
Sept 08 |
Nov 08 |
Jan. 09 |
The project is delayed by six months as a result of delays to the asset management project and to respond to management requests to focus on other evaluation work. |
| Learning Strategy Evaluation Framework |
Description and Framework |
A description of the Agency's learning strategy and objectives with a plan to evaluate objective achievement in the long term. |
Y |
Jan 07 |
Oct 08 |
Nov 08 |
Sept 08 |
The report was tabled December 12th 07 for approval but sent back for revisions and review by the Agency Human Resource Committee prior to re-tabling. Currently the Agency is in the process of developing a new learning policy and guidelines and developing a performance framework and HR dashboard that will include elements related to learning. Farther work on this project is postponed until these elements of the framework are in place. |
* Description and framework refers to describing the elements of a program or sub activity, its logic and systems for monitoring relevance and performance to support future evaluation projects. |
||||||||
Table 4: MAF Universe and Scheduled Audit Projects for 2008-2009 and 2009-2010
|
Rated Elements | Core Controls |
2008-2009 |
2009-2010 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Values and Ethics |
Values Based Leadership |
PSV-1 to 5 |
Audit |
||
| Governance |
Corporate Performance Framework |
G-3 |
|||
Effective Corporate Management Structures |
G-1, 2, 5, 6 |
||||
Organizational Structure and Accountability, |
AC-1 to 3 |
||||
Management Planning and Public Consultation |
G-4, 5 |
||||
Business Planning |
G-4 |
||||
Collaborative Arrangements and Managing With Others |
AC-4 |
Description and Survey |
Audit |
||
| Policies and Programs |
Analysis to support policy and program design |
PP-1 to 3 |
|||
| Performance and Results |
Performance/results |
RP 1 to 3 |
|||
| Management of Change |
Management of change, knowledge and talent management |
PPL-6, LICM-1-4 |
Description and Survey |
||
| Risk Management |
Risk Management Policies and Practices |
RM-1 to 8 |
Review Level Work |
||
| People |
Sustainable HR Policies and HR Planning |
PPL-1, 7 |
Description and Survey |
||
Classification, Recruitment, Hiring and Promotion |
PPL-2, 3 |
||||
Occupational Health and Safety |
|||||
Individual Performance |
PPL-5 RP-4 |
||||
Internal Communications |
PPL-8 |
||||
Official Languages (Internal And External Service Delivery) |
|||||
Labour Relations/Conflict Resolution |
|||||
| Stewardship |
Information Management and Privacy |
Description and Survey |
Audit |
||
Systems under development |
ST-21 |
Description and Survey |
|||
Systems and information continuity |
ST-19 |
||||
System application controls/security |
ST-11 |
||||
New System Integration/Connectivity |
|||||
Asset Management |
ST-8, 9 |
Fleet Vehicle /Vessel Audit |
|||
Project Management |
|||||
Realty Services (Land Management) |
|||||
Security and Business Continuity |
Description and Survey |
||||
Transfer Payments |
|||||
Pay and Benefits Administration |
Description and Survey Overtime System |
Follow-up of Pay and Benefits Audit (including overtime) |
|||
Financial Planning and Budgeting |
ST-1 to 4 |
Description and Survey National Level Management Control Framework |
Financial and Administrative Control Audits
|
|
|
Financial Management Policies |
ST-5, 6 |
||||
Transaction Processing |
ST-10, 12, 13 |
||||
Financial Monitoring |
ST-14, 16-17, 20 |
||||
Financial Reporting |
ST-18, 20 |
||||
Contract Management |
ST-22 |
||||
Other Expenditures (Hospitality, Travel, Taxis, Vehicle Rentals, AMEX, Conferences, Memberships) |
|||||
Fees i.e., entry, camping, recreational services |
|||||
Other Revenue |
|||||
Table 5: Internal Audit Project Scheduling for 2008-2009
| Projects | Planned or Actual Dates |
Resources Required* |
|||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Project |
Type |
Description |
Carry Forward from 2007-08 |
Start Date |
Completion of the fieldwork |
Completion of Report |
Tabling at Audit Committee |
Approximate hours |
O&M |
Value and Ethics |
Assurance |
Examining the Agency's policies and procedures to assess the effectiveness of core controls related to values and ethics to support the external audit committee in its oversight responsibilities. |
N |
Dec. 08 |
Feb 09 |
March 09 |
April 09 |
400 |
|
Collaborative Arrangements and Managing with Others |
Description and survey |
Document the types and range of the collaborative arrangements within the Agency and associated risks in controls to assist in planning future audit work |
Y |
June 08 |
March 09 |
April 09 |
600 |
$5K |
|
Sustainable HR Policies And HR Planning |
Description and Survey |
Document HR policies, plans and processes assess alignment with strategic plan and business plans, mechanisms for assessing compliance and renewing policies and plans. |
Y |
Dec. 08 |
May 09 |
Sept 09 |
600 |
||
Information Management and Privacy |
Description and Survey |
Document information management and privacy governance, risks and controls to plan future audit work |
Y |
June 08 |
Dec 08 |
March 09 |
April 09 |
700 |
|
Information Technology / Information system |
Description and Survey |
Document major IT governance, risks and controls related to systems, information continuity, system application controls/security, system integration and systems under development. A risk-based audit plan is to be delivered. |
Y |
April 08 |
Sept 08 |
Dec 08 |
Jan. 09 |
1100 |
$140K |
Fleet Vehicle/Vessel Management |
Assurance |
As a result of audits of financial controls it was decided to conduct assurance work on the controls and practices related to Parks Canada's fleet estimated to include over 1600 vehicles and vessels with an approximate value of $36M. |
N |
April 08 |
Sept 08 |
Dec 08 |
Jan. 09 |
1100 |
$25K |
National Level Finance & Administrative Management Control Framework |
Description and Survey |
Document the corporate management control framework for finance & administration processes to assist in providing an annual holistic opinion on the state of governance, risk management and control and to help identify future audit projects |
Y |
Jan 08 |
May 08 |
June 08 |
Sept 08 |
100 |
|
Financial and Administrative Control Audits |
Assurance |
Revenue Management |
Y |
June 08
|
Dec 08 |
March 09 |
April 09 |
1100 |
$25K |
Fire Management Emergency Funds |
Y |
April 08 |
Sept 08 |
Dec 08 |
Jan 09 |
1100
|
$5-10K |
||
Follow up Audit |
N |
Aug 08 |
Sept 08 |
Dec 08 |
Jan 09 |
400 |
$3K |
||
* Approximate hours reflect required effort within the fiscal year. Projects that extend beyond a fiscal year will require more effort than shown in the table. Staff or consultants may perform the work. O&M required includes costs of professional services and/or costs of staff travel. |
|||||||||
Table 6: PAA Universe and Five-Year Evaluation Schedule
| Sub Activities and Sub Sub-Activities (indented) |
Expenditures 2006-2007 |
2008-2009 |
2009-2010 |
2010-2011 |
2011-2012 |
2012-2013 |
|||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Heritage Places Establishment |
20,489 |
||||||||||
National Park Establishment and Expansion |
14,239 |
Description and Framework |
Evaluation |
||||||||
National Historic Sites Designation (Persons, Places, Events) |
4,753 |
||||||||||
National Marine Conservation Area Establishment |
82 |
Description and Framework |
|||||||||
Other Heritage Places Designations |
1,415 |
||||||||||
Heritage Resources Conservation |
193,989 |
||||||||||
National Parks Conservation |
126,985 |
Description and Framework |
Evaluation |
||||||||
Species at Risk |
|||||||||||
National Historic Sites Conservation |
49,763 |
Description and Framework |
Evaluation |
||||||||
National Marine Conservations Areas Sustainability |
1,466 |
Description and Framework |
|||||||||
Other Heritage Places Conservation |
15,775
|
||||||||||
National Historic Sites Cost-Sharing |
Evaluation |
||||||||||
Commercial Heritage Properties Incentive Fund |
|||||||||||
Historic Places Initiative |
|||||||||||
Public Appreciation and Understanding |
39,643 |
||||||||||
Outreach Education and Agency Communications |
|
Description and Framework |
|||||||||
Engagement |
|
||||||||||
Visitor Experience |
253,506 |
||||||||||
Marketing and Promotion |
14,316 |
Description and Framework |
|||||||||
National Parks Interpretation |
24,884 |
Description and Framework |
Evaluation |
||||||||
National Historic Sites Interpretation |
43,902 |
||||||||||
National Marine Conservation Areas Interpretation |
943 |
||||||||||
National Parks Visitor Activities and Services |
116,884 |
Description and Framework |
Evaluation |
||||||||
Public Safety |
|||||||||||
National Historic Sites Visitor Activities and Services |
51,606 |
||||||||||
National Marine Conservation Areas Visitor Activities and Services |
972 |
||||||||||
Town-Site and Throughway Infrastructure |
96,986 |
||||||||||
Townsite Management |
12,715 |
||||||||||
Through Highways Management |
75,145 |
Description and Framework |
Evaluation |
||||||||
Through Waterways Management |
9,125 |
||||||||||
| The General Class Contribution Program, which is not specific to one program activity or sub-activity, is to be evaluated in 2010-2011 | |||||||||||
Table 7: Evaluation Project Scheduling for 2008-2009
| Topic |
Type |
Description | Planned or Actual Dates |
Resources Required* 2008-2009 | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planned 2007-08 |
Start Date |
Completion of the fieldwork |
Completion of Report |
Date of Approval by Committee |
Approximate hours |
O&M |
|||
| Asset Management and Capital Investment Program |
Evaluation |
This evaluation focuses on whether relevant assets are acquired and maintained and whether performance with respect to investment, compliance regimes and other program goals are met. |
Y |
May 06 |
March 08 |
June 08 |
Sept 08 |
100 |
|
| Through Highways Management |
Description and Framework |
A description of the program sub-activity and objectives for and the systems in place to monitor relevance and performance as a basis for a subsequent evaluation. |
Y |
Jan 08 |
Sept 08 |
Nov 08 |
Jan. 09 |
800 |
$25K |
| Visitor Activities and Services |
Description and Framework |
A description of the program sub-activity and objectives and the systems in place to monitor relevance and performance as a basis for a subsequent evaluation |
N |
June 08 |
March 09 |
June 09 |
Sept 09 |
2600 |
$150K |
* Approximate hours reflect required effort. Projects that extend beyond a fiscal year will require more effort than shown in the table. Staff or consultants may perform the work. O&M required includes costs of professional services and/or costs of staff travel. |
|||||||||
Table 8: 2008-2009 Capacity For Internal Audit and Evaluation
| A) Resources |
CAEE Office |
Internal Audit |
Evaluation |
Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FTEs |
2 |
6 |
3 |
11 |
| Hours Available for Work (Less vacation, sick and training days, leaving 1,725 hours per FTE) |
3,450 |
10,350 |
5,175 |
18,975 |
| Professional Service Hours Purchased (O&M for professional Services/$160 per hour) |
110 |
978 |
1,521 |
2,610 |
| Total Hours Available |
3,560 |
11,328 |
6,696 |
21,585 |
| B) Demands |
||||
| Administration i.e., (70% of CAEE, 100% of Admin. Assistant and 30% of other staff hours are allocated for activities such as planning, meetings, work on internal systems, support to the audit and evaluation committee, training, breaks and general down time |
-2,933 |
-3,399 |
-2,009 |
-6,267 |
| OCG/TBS Directed Audits or Evaluations (25% of one FTE) |
|
-430 |
-430 |
-860 |
| Follow up from previous years (10% of one FTE) |
|
-175 |
-175 |
-350 |
| Special Requests |
|
-400 |
-400 |
-800 |
| Consulting/Advice/Coordination (35% of one FTE) |
|
-600 |
-600 |
-1,200 |
| Residual Hours for Risk Based Projects |
* |
6,638 |
3,395 |
10,033 |
| C) Project Capacity |
||||
| Number of Typical Projects: (Internal Audit=1200 hours per project, Evaluation=2200 hours per project) |
|
5.5 |
1.5 |
|
* Approximately 626 hours of project capacity in CAEE's Office were assigned equally to audit and evaluation. |
||||
Table 9: Comparison of 2008 and 2007 MAF Universe Elements and Links to Draft Core Management Controls
| Order |
Major MAF Element |
Element in MAF 5 TBS Assessment |
Rated Elements |
Order in 2007 Universe |
Link to Core Management Control Guide for Auditors |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 |
Public Service Values |
1 |
Values Based Leadership, values and ethics are established, understood, communicated, effective and monitored |
19 |
PSV-1 to 5 |
2 |
Governance |
2 |
Corporate Performance Framework (Consistency of strategic objective and PAA with mandate, clarity and measurability of outcomes, alignment of PAA with outcomes) |
2, 13 |
G-3 |
3 |
3 |
Effective Corporate Management Structures (e.g., Ex. Board, Finance and HR Committees, Min Roundtable, other governance mechanisms) |
1 |
G-1, 2, 5, 6 |
|
4 |
3 |
Organizational Structure and Accountability, Authority, Responsibility - Clear, Communicated And Understood |
14, 15 |
AC-1 to 3 |
|
5 |
3 |
Management Planning And Public Consultation (Integration with corporate planning, enables effective allocation of resources, alignment of activities to outcomes, clarity of results and management of accountabilities) |
4 |
G-4, 5 |
|
6 |
3 |
Business Planning: Integration with corporate and management planning, resource allocation to achieve results, clarity of results, adequate financial and non-financial information). |
5,6,8 |
G-4 |
|
7 |
3 |
Collaborative Arrangements And Managing With Others (Engagement of Third Parties in Delivery of Mandate) |
9-11 |
AC-4 |
|
8 |
Policy and Programs |
5 |
Analysis to support policy and program design: Quality, adequacy, soundness of analysis, resourcing, approach for monitoring |
16-17 |
PP-1 to 3 |
9 |
Results and Performance |
7 |
Performance/results: at the organizational/program level tracked/monitored against expectations, reported, corrective action taken |
12 |
RP 1 to 3 |
10 |
Change Management |
8 |
Management of change, knowledge and talent management, developing employee skills and rewards and sanctions |
23 |
PPL-6, LICM-1-4 |
11 |
Risk Management |
9 |
Risk Management Policies And Practices (Risk management process and risk mitigation strategies established, Informs the Corporate Plan, Formally Articulated) |
18 |
RM-1 to 8 |
12 |
People |
10, 11, 21 |
Sustainable HR Policies And HR Planning, aligned, integrated with other planning |
20 |
PPL-1, 7 |
13 |
Classification, Recruitment, Hiring and Promotion, Design and Fairness |
21 |
PPL-2, 3 |
||
14 |
Occupational Health And Safety |
22 |
|||
15 |
Individual Performance Linked to business performance, assessment of individual performance, performance linked to staff evaluations |
24 |
PPL-5 RP-4 |
||
16 |
Internal Communications |
25 |
PPL-8 |
||
17 |
Official Languages (Internal And External Service Delivery) |
26 |
|||
18 |
Labour Relations/Conflict Resolution |
27 |
|||
19 |
Stewardship |
12 |
Information Management And Privacy (Governance, management of information; Administration/Compliance Privacy Act and ATIP) |
28 |
|
20 |
13 |
Systems under development |
29 |
ST-21 |
|
21 |
Systems and information continuity |
30 |
ST-19 |
||
22 |
System application controls/security |
31 |
ST-11 |
||
23 |
New System Integration/Connectivity |
32 |
|||
24 |
14 |
Asset Management |
33 |
ST-8, 9 |
|
25 |
15 |
Project Management |
NA |
||
26 |
14 |
Realty Services (Land Management) |
35 |
||
27 |
19 |
Security and Business Continuity |
34, 36 |
||
28 |
Transfer Payments |
37 |
|||
29 |
Pay And Benefits Administration |
38 |
|||
30 |
17 |
Financial Planning and Budgeting (Budgets linked to objectives, clear process, timely allocation, challenge to assumptions, monitoring forecasts |
40, 41 |
ST-1 to 4 |
|
31 |
Financial Management Policies (Established, communicated, compliance, monitored) |
43, 44 |
ST-5, 6 |
||
32 |
Transaction Processing (Recording is accurate, timely, information is maintained, safeguarded, backed-up, adequate segregation of duties) |
45, 47, 48 |
ST-10, 12, 13 |
||
33 |
Monitoring (Verification of assets and records, analysis of variance, comparison of results achieved against expectations, reallocation of resources) |
46 |
ST-14, 16, 17, 20 |
||
34 |
Reporting (Financial information reviewed, approved, communicated internally and externally) |
ST-18, 20 |
|||
35 |
16 |
Contract Management |
49 |
ST-22 |
|
36 |
Other Expenditures (Hospitality, Travel, Taxis, Vehicle Rentals, AMEX, Conferences, Memberships) |
50-56 |
|||
37 |
Revenue From Fees i.e., entry, camping, recreational services |
57 |
|||
38 |
|
Other Revenue: Staff housing, Business Licenses, Other Rights and Privileges |
58-60 |
|
Table 10: Comparison of 2008 and 2007 PAA Universe Elements
| Rated Elements |
2006-2007 Expenditures |
Modified 2007 Universe Page 16-17 of Plan |
Original 2007 Universe Page 25 of Plan |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Heritage Places Establishment |
20,489 |
|||
1 |
National Park Establishment and Expansion |
14,239 |
1 |
1-2 |
2 |
National Historic Sites Designation (Persons, Places, Events) |
4,753 |
2 |
3 |
3 |
National Marine Conservation Area Establishment |
82 |
6 |
1 |
4 |
Other Heritage Places Designations |
1,415 |
5 |
4 |
| Heritage Resources Conservation |
193,989 |
|||
5 |
National Parks Conservation |
126,985 |
3 |
5-10 |
6 |
Species at Risk |
|
||
7 |
National Historic Sites Conservation |
49,763 |
4 |
11-13 |
8 |
National Marine Conservations Areas Sustainability |
1,466 |
6 |
5-10 |
9 |
Other Heritage Places Conservation |
15,775 |
5 |
14 |
10 |
National Historic Sites Cost-Sharing |
|
||
11 |
Commercial Heritage Properties Incentive Fund |
|
||
12 |
Historic Places Initiative |
|
||
| Public Appreciation and Understanding |
39,643 |
|||
13 |
Outreach Education and Agency Communications |
|
11 |
15-16 |
14 |
Engagement |
|
||
| Visitor Experience |
253,506 |
|||
15 |
Marketing and Promotion |
14,316 |
7 |
17-18 |
16 |
National Parks Interpretation |
24,884 |
8 |
22 |
17 |
National Parks Visitor Activities and Services |
43,902 |
19-21 |
|
18 |
Public Safety |
943 |
9 |
23 |
19 |
National Historic Sites Interpretation |
116,884 |
10 |
22 |
20 |
National Historic Sites Visitor Activities and Services |
|
19-21 |
|
21 |
National Marine Conservation Areas Interpretation |
51,606 |
6 |
22 |
22 |
National Marine Conservation Areas Visitor Activities and Services |
972 |
19-21 |
|
| Town-Site and Throughway Infrastructure |
96,986 |
|||
23 |
Townsite Management |
12,715 |
12 |
24-25 |
24 |
Through Highways Management |
75,145 |
13 |
26 |
25 |
Through Waterways Management |
9,125 |
14 |
27 |
Table 11: Comparison of MAF 2007 and 2008 Ratings
| # |
Sub Element | 2007 Assessment Priority (0-10) |
2008 Assessment Priority (-2 to +2) |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| N |
Average Rating |
|||
13 |
Risk Management Policies and Practices |
7.14 |
16 |
-0.78 |
27 |
Asset Management |
8.57 |
13 |
-0.48 |
7 |
Collaborative Arrangements and Managing With Others |
6.19 |
19.25 |
-0.27 |
21 |
Information Management and Privacy |
6.67 |
14 |
-0.27 |
26 |
New System Integration/Connectivity |
4.76 |
7 |
-0.14 |
28 |
Project Management |
NA |
10 |
-0.10 |
12 |
Management Of Change, Knowledge and Talent Management, |
5.24 |
17 |
-0.07 |
23 |
Systems Under Development |
5.71 |
8 |
-0.03 |
14 |
Sustainable HR Policies and HR Planning |
6.19 |
14.75 |
0.12 |
30 |
Security And Business Continuity |
5.00 |
7 |
0.14 |
46 |
Contract Management |
8.1 |
17 |
0.19 |
29 |
Realty Services (Land Management) |
5.24 |
10 |
0.23 |
9 |
Analysis to Support Policy and Program Design |
6.67 |
13.75 |
0.24 |
25 |
System Application Controls/Security |
4.76 |
6 |
0.33 |
5 |
Management Planning and Public Consultation |
3.33 |
16.5 |
0.35 |
41 |
Financial Monitoring |
4.29 |
15 |
0.52 |
4 |
Organizational Structure and Accountability, |
3.81 |
17 |
0.57 |
51 |
Other Revenue: Staff Housing, Business Licences, Other Rights and Privileges |
1.74 |
9 |
0.58 |
1 |
Values Based Leadership, |
4.76 |
19.5 |
0.62 |
24 |
Systems and Information Continuity |
5.71 |
6 |
0.63 |
34 |
Financial Planning, Budgeting, Forecasting |
3.8 |
16 |
0.66 |
11 |
Performance Tracking, Reporting, Responding |
9.52 |
18.75 |
0.69 |
15 |
Classification, Recruitment, Hiring And Promotion |
5.71 |
16.5 |
0.74 |
49 |
Other Revenue |
4.13 |
16 |
0.77 |
18 |
Internal Communications |
3.81 |
14.25 |
0.79 |
3 |
Effective Corporate Management Structures |
4.76 |
16.25 |
0.85 |
6 |
Business Planning |
4.28 |
18 |
0.85 |
17 |
Individual Performance Assessment |
4.76 |
13.5 |
0.89 |
50 |
Revenue From Fees |
8.57 |
11 |
1.00 |
19 |
Official Languages (Internal And External Service Delivery) |
2.86 |
15.75 |
1.03 |
32 |
Pay and Benefits Administration |
2.86 |
13 |
1.04 |
45 |
Financial Reporting |
NA |
18 |
1.08 |
38 |
Financial Transaction Processing |
3.01 |
16 |
1.13 |
2 |
Corporate Performance Framework |
2.62 |
18.75 |
1.20 |
31 |
Transfer Payments |
2.86 |
6 |
1.21 |
36 |
Financial Management Policies |
3.1 |
17 |
1.21 |
20 |
Labour Relations/Conflict Resolution |
1.43 |
12.75 |
1.22 |
16 |
Occupational Health and Safety |
5.71 |
15 |
1.33 |
Table 12: Results of 2008 MAF Assessement
(Average score per respondent across four questions for each element)
Table 13: Comparison of PAA 2007 and 2008 Ratings
| # |
Program Activities |
2006-2007 Expenditures |
2007 Assessment Priority (0-10) |
2008 Assessment Priority (-2 to +2) |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average |
|||||
| N |
Rating |
||||
| Heritage Places Establishment |
20,488.60 |
||||
1 |
National Park Establishment and Expansion |
14,239.10 |
5.56 |
11 |
0.64 |
2 |
National Historic Sites Designation (Persons, Places, Events) |
4,752.60 |
2.22 |
14.5 |
0.91 |
3 |
National Marine Conservation Area Establishment |
82.00 |
6.11* |
9.75 |
0.46 |
4 |
Other Heritage Places Designations |
1,414.90 |
5.00* |
14 |
0.43 |
| Heritage Resources Conservation |
193,989.20 |
||||
5 |
National Parks Conservation |
126,984.50 |
9.44 |
12.75 |
0.20 |
6 |
Species at Risk |
10 |
0.60 |
||
7 |
National Historic Sites Conservation |
49,763.40 |
6.81 |
17 |
0.41 |
8 |
National Marine Conservations Areas Sustainability |
1,466.20 |
6.11* |
7 |
-0.04 |
9 |
Other Heritage Places Conservation |
15,775.10 |
5.00* |
||
10 |
National Historic Sites Cost-Sharing |
8 |
-0.09 |
||
11 |
Commercial Heritage Properties Incentive Fund |
9 |
0.53 |
||
12 |
Historic Places Initiative |
8.25 |
0.70 |
||
| Public Appreciation and Understanding |
39,643.00 |
||||
13 |
Outreach Education and Agency Communications |
4.44* |
15.25 |
0.18 |
|
14 |
Engagement |
13.25 |
0.17 |
||
| Visitor Experience |
253,506.40 |
||||
15 |
Marketing and Promotion |
14,316.10 |
6.67 |
13 |
0.35 |
16 |
National Parks Interpretation |
24,883.80 |
6.11 |
11.75 |
0.87 |
17 |
National Parks Visitor Activities and Services |
116,884.40 |
10.5 |
0.69 |
|
18 |
Public Safety |
5.56 |
0.60 |
||
19 |
National Historic Sites Interpretation |
43,901.50 |
5.56 |
11.75 |
0.50 |
20 |
National Historic Sites Visitor Activities and Services |
51,605.90 |
10.5 |
0.50 |
|
21 |
National Marine Conservation Areas Interpretation |
942.60 |
6.11 |
6 |
0.25 |
22 |
National Marine Conservation Areas Visitor Activities and Services |
972.10 |
5 |
0.30 |
|
| Town-Site and Throughway Infrastructure |
96,985.60 |
||||
23 |
Townsite Management |
12,715.40 |
2.22 |
7 |
0.93 |
24 |
Through Highways Management |
75,145.40 |
7.78 |
9 |
-0.06 |
25 |
Through Waterways Management |
9,124.80 |
6.11 |
7 |
0.50 |
* Other heritage places establishment and conservation received one rating in 2007 that is shown separately against the two sub activities. Marine Conservation Area establishment, sustainability and visitor experience received one rating in 2007 shown against each sub-activity. |
|||||
Table 14: Result of 2008 PAA Assessment
(Average score per respondent across four questions)
[ Previous | Table of Contents ]